The Gardener of the Sacred Greenhouse

  “The greenhouse is my symbol for the whole of life, a womb, a heaven-on-earth.”

Theodore Roethke (1908-63) was one of the half dozen or so most prominent American poets of the 2nd half of the 20th century, awarded the Pulitzer and Bollinger Prizes and two National Book Awards. Although he lived only 55 years, he was a popular poet and influential teacher, and also one of the more notably spiritual poets in the history of American literature, actually clearly experiencing higher states of consciousness and describing them with great beauty, simplicity, creativity, and clarity.

“Theodore Huebner Roethke is regarded as one of the most accomplished and influential poets of his generation, having won the Pulitzer Prize for Poetry in 1954 for his book The Waking, and the annual National Book Award for Poetry on two occasions: in 1959 for Words for the Wind, and posthumously in 1965 for The Far Field. His work was characterized by a willingness to engage deeply with a multifaceted introspection, and his style was overtly rhythmic, with a skillful use of natural imagery. Indeed, Roethke’s mastery of both free verse and fixed forms was complemented by an intense lyrical quality that drew “from the natural world in all its mystery and fierce beauty.” Roethke was praised by former U.S. Poet Laureate and author James Dickey as “in my opinion the greatest poet this country has yet produced.” He was also a respected poetry teacher, and taught at the University of Washington for fifteen years. His students from that period won two Pulitzer Prizes for Poetry and two others were nominated for the award. “He was probably the best poetry-writing teacher ever,” said poet Richard Hugo, who studied under Roethke.” (Wikipedia)

Wikipedia’s article on Roethke also makes it clear that he chose to endure the ‘daemons and demons’ that often attend a person who braves the depths of consciousness, of confrontation or involvement with the Infinite – the actual experience of the Infinite, the Absolute. “Nothing is so purifying than knowledge.” (Krishna). The spiritual path is a path of detoxification, purification, the dark days and nights of the soul. Rilke dealt with these for most of his life, and chose to do this without the solace of a tradition or guide, taking the rough hewn path of alcohol and mental instability instead – common among poets and philosophers throughout the ages in the West, especially in Roethke’s Hiroshima generation.

Roethke was brought up in a greenhouse family in Saginaw, Michigan, and his early writing is an  exquisitely creative and fresh description of nature, the seasons, and plants (especially in the second section of his first book Open House), which instantly established him as a major poet and poetic influence. At the end of this period, Roethke realized he was in the ‘prison’ or dream of the ordinary waking state of consciousness, and that he didn’t know how to exit (‘Who knows/ The way out of a rose?”). Aware of the hermit and recluse approach to this situation, he knew he was not made for that life. So his response to this situation (in contrast to some other poets such as Eliot who had had the same realization), instead of searching, seeking, or shopping for or adopting an ‘ism,’ was to ‘take his waking slow,’ ie., simply accept his spiritual childhood and continue living and writing and see what happened.

This led to Roethke’s middle period of writing, characterized by relatively disjointed, disparate word units. This style fit into the taste and style of the day in the U.S. so was well-received, and it was part of the breaking up of normal poetic language and meaning that was in full process in English literature throughout the first half of the 20th century. This ‘deconstruction’ or ‘deformation’ of poetic form had begun in the Romantic period; the Victorian interlude then reacted against it, and poetic form moved back toward formal design, meter, and use of sound; Browning then again broke with form, Pound  propounded it, then Eliot led the massive onslaught against form, making it elegant and finished, a little more palatable and accessible, and therefore established and acceptable, in his early writing such as Prufock, establishing lack of form as a long-term ‘fad,’ and eventually a permanent option in poetic composition.

This less structured period of Roethke, simply put, a) reflected the deconstruction of lower non-enlightened ‘normal’ human experience he was having, and b) helped to further the process of deconstructing that ‘ordinary’ non-normality (higher states of consciousness are normal, non-higher states of consciousness are subnormal).

This middle period of Roethke helped maintain the momentum of this more informal, elusive, less accessible writing, with unusual, unconventional phraseology and meaning so characteristic of the first half of the 20th century (which shows little sign of abating in 2011, although there has been a shift from poetry that is challenging to understand, to poetry that is not desirable to understand). Theodore Roethke seemed to start down that road, but was not to continue, and ended up a representative of writing that returned to the lucidity, clarity, simplicity, life-affirming but still highly creative and poetic straightforwardness, of his, and English literature’s, earlier, more innocent, times, but with a new, higher, maturity and depth.

Because the solidity of Roethke’s ‘waking state cage’ was not to continue – his broken-up style was part of the process of the breaking up of the confines of the waking state of consciousness and superficial ‘normality’ of his younger years. Infinite awareness began poking holes in the cloth of his ordinary reality, which led to his third and final period of writing, which contains highly creative and beautiful poems that directly reflect his clear experiences of higher states of consciousness, contained most abundantly in his final book The Far Field, published posthumously in 1964 and winner of the National Book Award.

Poets who write about higher consciousness often tend to favor Nature as their primary subject. Roethke started with Nature, turned toward society in his ‘broken up’ years, then returned to Nature as he grew into a greater, even infinite, wholeness of awareness. Nature and Wholeness tend to be found together.

In his transition from ordinary waking consciousness to frequent experiences of higher states of consciousness, Roethke experienced, and described well, the intense spiritual heat and light of the deep ‘burning away’ of the fabric of limitation of consciousness (referred to in past spiritual literature as purgation), a process he was strong enough to weather and to a great extent master. The poems at the end of his middle period show the blissful expansive ups and searing downs, the rises and falls, that can attend deep spiritual transformation, especially when one is making that journey alone, as did T.S. Eliot, Wallace Stevens, and so many others before them: The Waking [I], A Field of Light, The Shape of the Fire, Praise to the End!, Old Lady’s Winter Words, The Vigil, The Waking [II], The Pure Fury, The Renewal. The Longing, The Abyss, In a Dark Time, The Sequel, Infirmity, The Decision, The Marrow, I Waited, The Restored

‘North American Sequence,’ a group of six poems that begins The Far Field, exemplifies Roethke’s fully mature, now again unbroken style, and deeply spiritual content, which has been compared to Whitman, who also experienced (or at least intuitively sensed) supreme reality in higher states of consciousness in abundance and wrote clearly and directly about them. The fourth section of The Far Field (‘Sequence, Sometimes Metaphysical’) also is particularly exemplary of his clear spiritual perception and level of experience expressed in incredibly beautiful lines. Theodore Roethke was born to find Something and tell the story clearly and beautifully. He found It and told It, and left as soon as he was finished, with a flourish.

The following poems (from The Collected Poems of Theodore Roethke, Anchor Doubleday) best express Roethke’s unification of higher states of consciousness and literary beauty. Most of these are in Sections I, III, and IV of The Far Field.

The Vigil  p. 103                                  The Long Waters  p. 190                    Infirmity  p. 236

Words for the Wind  p. 118                The Far Field  p. 193                           I Waited  p. 239

The Renewal  p. 130                            The Abyss  p. 211                                The Tree, the Bird  p. 240

Her Becoming  p. 159                          The Tranced  p. 229                            The Restored  p. 241

Meditation at Oyster Bay  p. 184      The Moment  p. 230                           The Right Thing  p. 242

Journey to the Interior  p. 187           In a Dark Time  p. 231                        Once More, the Round  p. 243

Other Poems of great beauty, or hinted spirituality, or both:

The Adamant  p. 9                               A Field of Light  p. 59               The Decision  p. 237

The Light Comes Brighter  p. 10       The Shape of the Fire  p. 61               The Marrow  p. 238

Slow Season  p. 11                             Praise to the End!  p. 81                     Light Poem  p. 247

In Praise of Prairie  p. 12                     Old Lady’s Winter Words  p. 99         Meditation in Hydrotherapy

The Coming of the Cold  p. 13            The Waking [II]  p. 104                          p. 248

Reply to Censure  p. 19                       The Pure Fury  p. 128                          Lines Upon Leaving a  

Vernal Sentiment  p. 23                     A Walk in Late Summer  p. 143         Sanitarium  p. 249  

Ballad of the Clairvoyant Widow      The Dying Man  p. 147                       Song  p. 250  

   p. 25                                                 The Longing  p. 181                            The Changeling  p. 252

Lull  p. 29                                            Her Time  p. 203                                 The Follies of Adam  p. 254

Night Journey  p. 32                            Light Listened  p. 205                          The Centaur  p. 256

Double Feature  p. 45            The Happy Three  p. 206                    The Harsh Country  p. 257

Last Words  p. 46                                 In Evening Air  p. 232                          The Reply  p. 263

Night Crow  p. 47                                 The Sequel  p. 233                              Duet  p. 264

The Waking [I]  p. 49                           The Motion  p. 236          

Edited from Wikipedia:

“Two-time US Poet Laureate Stanley Kunitz said of Roethke, “The poet of my generation who meant most to me, in his person and in his art, was Theodore Roethke.”…Yale literary critic Harold Bloom cites…Roethke on his list of essential writers and books, [and] groups Roethke with Elizabeth Bishop and Robert Penn Warren as the most accomplished among the “middle generation” of American poets…Camille Paglia includes three Roethke poems, more than any other 20th-century writer cited in the book. W. H. Auden called [Roethke’s first book] Open House “completely successful.” In another review of the book, Elizabeth Drew felt “his poems have a controlled grace of movement and his images the utmost precision; while in the expression of a kind of gnomic wisdom which is peculiar to him as he attains an austerity of contemplation and a pared, spare strictness of language very unusual in poets of today.” … critics picked up on the self as the predominant preoccupation in Roethke’s poems.. 

“In addition to the well-known greenhouse poems, the Poetry Foundation notes that Roethke also won praise “for his love poems… a distinct departure from the painful excavations of the monologues and in some respects a return to the strict stanzaic forms of the earliest work,’…Ralph Mills described ‘the amatory verse’ as a blend of ‘consideration of self with qualities of eroticism and sensuality; but more important, the poems introduce and maintain a fascination with something beyond the self, that is, with the figure of the other, or the beloved woman.'”…Karl Malkoff of The Sewanee Review wrote: “Though not definitive, Roethke: Collected Poems is a major book of poetry. It reveals the full extent of Roethke’s achievement: his ability to perceive reality in terms of the tensions between inner and outer worlds, and to find a meaningful system of metaphor with which to communicate this perception…. It also points up his weaknesses: the derivative quality of his less successful verse, the limited areas of concern in even his best poems. The balance,.. is in Roethke’s favor…. He is one of our finest poets, a human poet in a world that threatens to turn man into an object.”

“In 1967 Roethke’s Collected Poems topped the lists of two of the three Pulitzer Prize poetry voters; Phyllis McGinley and Louis Simpson. However the group’s chairman, Richard Eberhart, lobbied against Roethke on the grounds that the award should go to a living poet; it would have been Roethke’s second Pulitzer Prize.” 

Teacher of Teachers, creating great poets left and right, Theodore Roethke will continue teaching us long as green sprouts split the soil to scale the close sky.